17+ years · AFSP · Audit protection included · 100% remote · Christian-owned family firm

For pastors

Pastor didn’t pay self-employment tax on housing? How to fix past returns

It’s one of the most common clergy tax mistakes, and it’s fixable. Here’s what usually went wrong, which years can be corrected, and what to expect from interest and penalties.

First, take a breath

If you’ve just learned that your self-employment tax may not have been figured correctly, you’re in good company. Pastors and churches get this wrong all the time, often because nobody ever explained the rules. The fix is usually straightforward, the IRS has clear ways to handle it, and correcting it on your own is far better than waiting for a letter.

The two most common situations

What self-employment tax should include

For Social Security and Medicare, a pastor’s ministry earnings are self-employment income (IRC §1402(c); IRC §3121(b)(8)). The SE-tax base generally includes:

The tax is 15.3% on 92.35% of that amount (the Social Security part is capped at $184,500 of earnings for 2026), and you get an income tax deduction for half of it. That’s why the housing allowance matters so much: for illustration only, a $25,000 housing allowance left off Schedule SE adds about $3,500 of SE tax per year.

Source: IRS Publication 517, Self-Employment Tax: Figuring Net Earnings, Amounts included in gross income.

How the fix works

The usual fix is to amend each open year with Form 1040-X and a corrected Schedule SE, adding the missing earnings and the deduction for half of the SE tax. Which years are “open” depends on two time limits:

As of late 2026, for returns filed on time, that generally means 2023, 2024, and 2025 are the open years. A 2023 return filed by its April 2024 due date stays open until April 15, 2027. Then the current year gets filed correctly going forward.

When the church withheld FICA, the cleanest correction can also involve the church filing corrected W-2s (Form W-2c) and payroll returns (Form 941-X). That’s the church’s decision, and whether it’s needed depends on the years and amounts. A preparer who knows clergy returns can sort out the right approach for your situation. Going forward, share our W-2 guide for churches with your treasurer.

Interest and penalties: what to expect

If you can’t pay it all at once

The IRS makes payment plans simple. Individuals who owe $50,000 or less in combined tax, penalties, and interest can usually set up a monthly plan online, and a short-term plan (up to 180 days) is available for balances under $100,000. See IRS payment plans.

Keeping it right from here

Related guides

Free review of your past returns

Cameron is glad to review your past returns at no charge and tell you plainly whether anything needs to be corrected. You only pay if amended returns are actually needed, and we’ll explain exactly what’s involved before any work begins. Please send your returns and W-2s for the last few years to get started.

Cameron Koch Tax Services LLC prepares returns remotely for pastors and clergy nationwide and for missionaries serving abroad. New clients can ask about $25 off their first return, and every return includes free audit assistance and tax identity theft protection. Send a note through the contact page or upload your documents securely.

This page is general information, not legal or tax advice for your situation. The example is an illustration only. Time limits, interest rates, and penalty rules can change, and every situation is different. Check current IRS instructions and your tax preparer before relying on it.