17+ years · AFSP · Audit protection included · 100% remote · Christian-owned family firm

For church treasurers

Should a pastor receive a W-2 or a 1099?

It’s one of the most common questions church treasurers ask. For most staff pastors the answer is a W-2, even though the pastor still pays self-employment tax. Here’s why.

The short answer

A pastor your church hires, supervises, and pays a regular salary should almost always get a Form W-2. A guest speaker, visiting evangelist, or occasional pulpit-supply preacher usually gets a Form 1099-NEC (if paid enough) or nothing at all. What decides it isn’t the title “minister”; it’s the ordinary employee-versus-contractor test.

Why pastors confuse everyone: dual status

Ministers have dual tax status. For income tax, a staff pastor is usually a common-law employee. For Social Security and Medicare, the same pastor is treated as self-employed and pays self-employment tax personally. So a pastor can get a W-2 and still pay self-employment tax. That’s normal, and it isn’t a reason to issue a 1099 instead.

Sources: IRS Publication 517, Common-law employee; IRS Topic 417; IRC §§3121(b)(8) and 1402(c).

The common-law employee test

The IRS says a minister is generally an employee “if the church or organization you perform services for has the legal right to control both what you do and how you do it, even if you have considerable discretion and freedom of action.” Signs that your pastor is an employee:

The U.S. Tax Court has applied this test to pastors and found a senior pastor to be an employee for income tax (Weber v. Commissioner, 103 T.C. 378 (1994)). A pastor’s freedom in preaching and counseling doesn’t change the overall picture.

When a 1099-NEC is right

Source: IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC; IRS Publication 1099 (2026).

Why getting it right matters

What a staff pastor’s W-2 should look like

Box 1 shows taxable pay without the housing allowance; Box 2 shows only voluntary income tax withholding; Boxes 3 through 6 stay blank; and the housing allowance goes in Box 14. Our step-by-step W-2 guide for churches walks through each box, along with Form 941.

Related guides

Setting up payroll for your pastor?

Treasurers are welcome to reach out with questions. And if your pastor needs help with his or her own return, including self-employment tax and the housing allowance, that’s our specialty.

Cameron Koch Tax Services LLC prepares returns remotely for pastors and clergy nationwide and for missionaries serving abroad. New clients can ask about $25 off their first return, and every return includes free audit assistance and tax identity theft protection. Send a note through the contact page or upload your documents securely.

This page is general information, not legal or tax advice for your situation. Worker status depends on the facts, and reporting thresholds can change. Check current IRS instructions and your own tax advisor before relying on it.