17+ years · AFSP · Audit protection included · 100% remote · Christian-owned family firm

For church treasurers

How churches should prepare a pastor’s W-2

Pastors are taxed differently from everyone else on your payroll. Here’s a plain-words guide to getting the W-2 and Form 941 right for 2026 and the years ahead.

The one rule that explains everything

Pastors have what the IRS calls dual tax status. For federal income tax, a pastor your church hires and pays a salary is usually a common-law employee, so he or she gets a Form W-2. For Social Security and Medicare, the same pay is treated as self-employment income. The pastor pays those taxes personally as self-employment (SE) tax on Schedule SE, not through your payroll.

That comes straight from the tax code: services a minister performs in the exercise of ministry are excluded from FICA “employment” (IRC §3121(b)(8)) and are brought under the self-employment tax instead (IRC §1402(c)(2)(D) and (c)(4)). IRS Publication 15-A puts it plainly: whether the minister is an employee or self-employed, “the earnings of a minister aren’t subject to federal income, social security, and Medicare tax withholding.”

Sources: IRS Publication 15-A (2026), section 4, Religious Exemptions and Special Rules for Ministers; IRS Publication 517.

Who these rules cover

These rules apply to ministers who are duly ordained, commissioned, or licensed and who are paid for services in the exercise of their ministry, such as preaching, leading worship, and administering ordinances or sacraments. Other staff members (an office administrator, custodian, or a worship leader who isn’t a credentialed minister) are regular employees, and their pay is subject to normal Social Security and Medicare withholding.

The pastor’s W-2, box by box

W-2 boxWhat to report for your pastor
Box 1: WagesAll taxable pay: salary, bonuses, Christmas or appreciation gifts paid through the church, any “SE tax allowance” or offset, and any expense allowance paid under a nonaccountable plan. Leave out the designated housing allowance (and the value of a parsonage). Pre-tax 403(b) deferrals also come out of Box 1.
Box 2: Federal income tax withheldOnly what you withheld under a voluntary agreement with the pastor (see below). Otherwise leave it blank.
Boxes 3, 4, 5, and 6Leave blank. No Social Security or Medicare wages, and no Social Security or Medicare tax withheld.
Box 12Normal codes still apply, for example code E for 403(b) elective deferrals.
Box 14: OtherThe housing allowance, labeled clearly, for example “Housing allowance $24,000.” IRS guidance allows Box 14 or a separate statement to the pastor; Box 14 is the simplest.

Pub. 15-A: “Don’t include a parsonage allowance (excludable housing allowance) in this amount [Box 1]” and “Don’t show on Form W-2, Form 941, or Form 944 any amount as social security or Medicare wages, or any withholding for social security or Medicare tax.”

Voluntary withholding: a big help for your pastor

Because nothing is withheld for Social Security and Medicare, many pastors face a large bill in April. Your church can help by agreeing to voluntary federal income tax withholding. The pastor fills out a Form W-4 and can ask for an extra amount per paycheck (Step 4(c)) large enough to cover both income tax and SE tax.

Form 941 and Form 940

What if the pastor has an approved Form 4361?

Nothing changes on your end. A minister with an approved Form 4361 exemption is still not subject to FICA withholding, so the W-2 looks the same: Boxes 3 through 6 stay blank. The exemption only affects whether the pastor owes SE tax on his or her own return. Federal income tax still applies, and voluntary withholding is still available.

Common mistakes we see

Getting it right going forward

If your church has been doing any of the above, don’t panic. This is very common, and the easiest fix is to start correctly with the next calendar year. Here’s a simple checklist for 2027 payroll:

PASTOR PAYROLL CHECKLIST FOR 2027 1. Set the pastor up in payroll as a minister: no Social Security or Medicare withholding, and no employer share. 2. Before January 1, adopt the 2027 housing allowance in writing (board or congregational minutes). 3. Ask the pastor whether he or she wants voluntary federal income tax withholding (Form W-4, with any extra amount on Step 4(c)). 4. Each paycheck: report salary minus the housing allowance as taxable wages; withhold only federal (and any state) income tax the pastor requested. 5. Form 941: leave the pastor’s pay out of Social Security and Medicare wages. 6. W-2 in January 2028: Box 1 salary (excluding housing), Box 2 any voluntary withholding, Boxes 3–6 blank, Box 14 “Housing allowance” and the amount.

Most payroll services and software have a “clergy” or “minister” setting that handles this automatically; ask your provider to switch it on. If past years were reported incorrectly, a church can correct prior W-2s with Form W-2c and its payroll returns with Form 941-X. Whether that’s worth doing depends on the years and amounts involved, so talk it over with your own tax advisor. On the pastor’s side, see how pastors can fix past returns.

Also helpful: our main housing allowance guide and worksheet and IRS Publication 517 in plain English.

Related guides

Questions about your church’s payroll?

Church treasurers are welcome to reach out with questions about setting up a pastor’s payroll. And if your pastor needs help with his or her own return, including self-employment tax and the housing allowance, that’s our specialty.

Cameron Koch Tax Services LLC prepares returns remotely for pastors and clergy nationwide and for missionaries serving abroad. New clients can ask about $25 off their first return, and every return includes free audit assistance and tax identity theft protection. Send a note through the contact page or upload your documents securely.

This page is general information, not legal or tax advice for your situation. Payroll rules, form line numbers, and state requirements can change, and every church is different. Check current IRS instructions and your own tax advisor before relying on it.